Quick answer: after the first birthday, food should gradually become your child's main source of nutrition, with milk as a drink alongside it. Singapore's early childhood guidelines recommend offering whole milk and water to toddlers. A European paediatric nutrition society advises keeping cow's milk under 500ml a day for toddlers, because too much can crowd out iron-rich food. Most children do well on a couple of cups a day plus a varied diet.
Milk is one of the most common worries we hear from parents of younger children. Some toddlers seem to live on it and barely touch their lunch. Others refuse it entirely. In between are many families privately wondering whether they should still be buying the growing-up formula in the big tin, and whether their child will miss out if they stop.
What changes after the first birthday
For the first year, milk is the main event. Breast milk or infant formula provides most of what a baby needs, and solid food is about learning to eat.
From one year onwards, that balance flips. The Singapore Integrated 24-Hour Activity Guidelines for Early Childhood, published by the College of Paediatrics and Child Health, say toddlers should be weaned off milk as their main source of nutrition. They should move towards healthy family meals and a regular routine of meals and snacks. For drinks, the guidelines recommend whole milk and water.
Milk still matters as a good source of calcium and protein. It simply takes its place as one part of the day's food rather than the whole of it.
How much is enough, and how much is too much
There is no single figure that suits every child, and needs depend on how much else they eat. As a guide, the European Society for Paediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition advises that cow's milk intake for toddlers be kept below 500ml a day. That is roughly two standard cups.
The reason for the upper limit matters. Milk is filling but contains very little iron. A toddler who drinks large amounts of milk often has little appetite left for iron-rich foods such as meat and leafy greens, and high milk intake is one of the recognised risk factors for iron deficiency in young children. Iron is essential for growth and brain development, and a shortage can leave a child tired and pale.
Signs that milk may be taking over:
- Your child drinks well but eats very little at meals.
- They ask for milk whenever they are bored or upset.
- Bottles are still a big part of the night.
- They are often constipated.
If any of these sound familiar, the fix is usually gentle and gradual.
Growing-up milk or fresh milk?
This is where Singapore parents face the most noise. Growing-up milks for toddlers are heavily advertised, often with claims about brain development and immunity.
For a healthy child who eats a reasonably varied diet, Singapore's national guidelines recommend whole milk and water, and they do not call for special formula after the first year. If you do use a growing-up milk, read the label. Some contain added sugars, and flavoured versions often contain more. The 24-hour guidelines advise that sugar-sweetened drinks should not be given before the age of two and should be avoided as much as possible after that.
There are good reasons a doctor might recommend a particular formula for a particular child, such as a diagnosed allergy or concerns about growth. In those cases, follow your doctor's advice.
If you are still breastfeeding, there is no need to stop simply because your child has turned one.
Whole milk or low fat?
For toddlers, the guidelines recommend whole milk. Young children need the energy and fat for growth, and low-fat milks are generally introduced later, if at all. Ask your doctor if you have a particular reason to consider a change, such as a family history of heart problems.
If your child cannot or will not drink milk
Some children have a cow's milk allergy or intolerance. Others just dislike it. Calcium can come from other foods:
- Plain yoghurt and cheese.
- Calcium-set tofu, which is easy to find in Singapore supermarkets and wet markets.
- Ikan bilis and canned fish with edible bones, such as sardines.
- Green leafy vegetables like kai lan and bok choy.
- Unsweetened, calcium-fortified soy drinks.
Plant-based drinks vary a great deal in protein and calcium. If you are planning to use one as your child's main milk, check with your doctor first.
Moving from bottle to cup
Somewhere after the first birthday is a good time to start moving milk from bottle to cup. By two, many children can drink from an open cup with a bit of spilling. Drinking from an open cup is one of the life skills on our age-by-age list for two-year-olds.
A few ways to make the change:
- Start with the easiest feed. Usually the midday one, when your child is distracted and busy. Offer milk in a cup with lunch.
- Let them choose the cup. A cup they picked at the shop is more interesting than a bottle.
- Shorten the bedtime bottle. Make it smaller over a week or two, then move it earlier in the routine, before teeth are brushed.
- Replace comfort with comfort. If the bottle was about soothing, swap in a long cuddle with a book.
- Stop the night bottles. Milk on the teeth through the night is hard on them, and toddlers rarely need night feeds for nutrition.
Expect a few grumpy days. Most toddlers adjust within a week or so when parents are calm and consistent.
Drinks at school
At Shaws, meals and snacks are cooked in our own kitchen and the menu includes no sugary drinks. Every child brings a water bottle they can open themselves, which is on the packing list for the first day. You can read more about food and meals in our first-day guide.
When to seek advice
Talk to your doctor if your child drinks a lot of milk and eats very little. The same goes for a child who seems unusually pale or is not growing as expected. Ongoing constipation is worth mentioning too. They may suggest a simple blood test to check iron levels. A dietitian can also help if your child has a restricted diet because of allergies.
Shaws Preschool has welcomed children from 18 months across the East Coast and Serangoon since 1989, with every meal cooked in-house. Come and see a lunchtime for yourself: book a tour.